2009 is kicking off with international intrigue.
According to an official Tokyopop Germany newsletter, which has been reposted on their official BBS, Kodansha has not renewed its licensing agreement with the company, effectively cancelling all Kodansha-owned releases mid-run. The affected books include Beck, School Rumble, Hell Girl, and Cromartie High School. (Whoa, they can do that? So… why are we waiting for ADV to finish up Cromartie?)
I’m going by a Babelfish translation here, but it appears that this was not due to any lapse on the part of Tokyopop Germany, who were caught by surprise… they held dicussions with Kodansha, but were neither able to convince them to reconsider, nor were they successful in coaxing an explanation.
There are plenty of possibilities, and not many of them bode well for Tokyopop. Is TP Germany a victim of soured relationships at the parent company? Is this another clue to Kodansha’s international manga ambitions? Has Del Rey been posting recruitment ads for German translators recently? Absent any explanation from the above parties, I’m tilting away from this being isolated to the German arm alone. But there is another potential avenue to explore… Carlsen and Egmont are German publishers who also hold Kodansha manga titles, so whether or not they experience similar issues in the coming months (or perhaps, pick up a bunch of new licenses) may give Kodansha’s actions some context.
If there are any subtleties in the forum post that didn’t come through the machine translation, please enlighten me.
Edit: Oh, and apparently there is a German equivalent of Del Rey… Random House imprint Heyne publishes Kodansha manga exclusively (at least according to the list of titles on ANN), including Air Gear, Genshiken, and Flower of Eden, curiously.
Edit 2: Comics212′s Christopher Butcher offers additional insight.
+++
ComiPress has links to coverage of Comic Market 75, which was held on the last three days of 2008.
+++
Missed it… writing for Digital Strips, Brigid Alverson examines Manganovel’s demise and questions, among other things, the wisdom of incorporating fan translations in its business model. I don’t particularly disagree with Ms. Alverson’s observations about the scanlation community’s insular nature, but I doubt it was a contributing factor when there were so many other things already going against Manganovel, namely the lack of major manga licenses, and the general monetization difficulties almost all such online publishing efforts face.
+++
Well, it looks like Mania finally done broke AnimeOnDVD and “TP-fied” it. Sigh.
Anyway… Chris Beveridge writes about the 5 things anime publishers got right this year. He also wrote about the 5 things the industry did wrong, but I can’t find it anymore amid all the rollover links and embedded videos. Why does every page load 500+ items?
Hopefully, we’ll see a similar write-up for the manga industry…
Edit: Here’s the 5 things anime companies did wrong article (thanks, Fezmonkey).
-
Mania/AoD: I can’t believe they redesigned the whole site only to make it even harder to navigate.
And yet I made an account to enter the drawing for that Kara no Kyoukai figure. I am such a sell out.
-
Heh, yeah. All that new stuff killed my 56k.
That was a good read though, as was the comiket info and the manga cafe from the last post. Had no idea HD was back online. Thanks for keeping us up to date. Weird goings on with TP Germany. Ergh.. guess we can only wish them the best and hope it doesn’t hit us. I couldn’t stand losing my School Rumble fix.
…nice new banner :)
-
@Simon
Flower of Eden has been stopped in Germany, too. Heyne stopped a lot of series they were publishing, like Life, Yagyu Ninpo Chou, Gacha Gacha etc. I don’t really know wether it has to do with sales or with Kodansha (I haven’t checked if some of those series are from Kodansha). Currently they’re only publishing three or four series, for example Air Gear and Mamotte Lolipop.And you didn’t miss anything, Babelfish did it’s job for once. XD
-
Whoa, even I was surprised when I went to AoD today. I have known the integration into a full mania site has been coming, but it still took me by surprise.
Simon is right about sites following that ‘overload your brain’ visual style. It is unfortunate, but we have to do what we can to survive. The alternative would have been to see AoD die completely this year like Broccoli Books, or slow to a crawl and leave the cyberworld wondering if AoD was really dead or not, like Infinity Studios.
The forums will remain the same, but I do think there is some potential to the mania portal, although it definitely creates a problem for anyone running 56k. For instance, AoD Recommends has been resurrected http://www.mania.com/aod-recommends_category_154.html.
As for the loading problem with the player window in the middle, if you look at the top right there is a ‘play’ button triangle. Press it and it will switch the data over to a RSS looking feed with a few filter options. Yes I know that doesn’t get rid of all the advertisements, but it should definitely help with the 56k people.
-
Here’s the alternate AoD link (which is mostly image free):
http://www.mania.com/anime_manga_oav_ova_dvd_summary_143.html
-
Here’s the top 5 things they did wrong article:
http://www.mania.com/top-five-things-anime-companies-did-wrong-2008_article_111940.html
-
Now it seems that mania.com itself is broken — been getting a “Page Load Error” (“Connection Interrupted / The connection to the server was reset while the page was loading”) all day today when I try to reach anything on AoD or mania.com’s main page.
-
Sigh, and I thought Mania was bad before. Now the scrolling’s all choppy and slow. This is gonna make browsing the forums a real pain… @_@
-
Dear Simon,
since you bring up the question regarding “potential announcements” from other publishers of Kodansha titles, I can confirm that the news above is not related to Kodansha titles published or announced by Carlsen Manga.
Kind regards
Kai-Steffen Schwarz
Editorial Director Manga
Carlsen Verlag GmbH
Germany















18 comments
Comments feed for this article
Trackback link: http://www.icaruscomics.com/wp_web/wp-trackback.php?p=2283