Amazon UK runs afoul of violent porn ban? | Viz original content on hold

The Belfast Telegraph is reporting that Amazon UK had available for sale (and since pulled) a Japanese PC eroge called RapeLay, which supposedly simulates the rape of a woman and her two daughters, though I think it’s the forced abortion segment that truly makes this game “special”.  One parliament member angrily vowed to make a stink at the next parliament session, despite there being no evidence that the game was actually imported into the UK.  (Britain recently enacted a law that criminalizes production and distribution of fictional depictions of violent sex, excluding film, curiously.)

One point that may be intentionally overlooked by Belfast Telegraph for the sake of sensationalism is that the item does not appear to have been made available by Amazon UK directly, but rather a third party using Amazon USA’s independent seller program that is more notorious in the states as a source of “professionally” pirated anime DVDs.  If the Belfast Telegraph article’s claim that the game was available to UK buyers is correct (I doubt it), and the Japanese developer’s site specifically states their games are not for sale outside of the US, there is a small possibility that what was offered was an unauthorized counterfit, or even warez someone burned onto DVD-R in their basement.

You know, I think Western media loves stories that portray Japan as crazy sex world, especially when it comes to manga and anime, but in my experience (ahem) hardcore bondage/S&M is just as prevalent, if not a more popular theme in European porno comics.  They just don’t seem to have the kind of online visibility that manga does.

+++

Ooh, I have not seen this anywhere else… author Tina Anderson reveals that Viz’s original content program, which was first brought to light after calls for submissions/portfolio reviews at several anime and comic conventions, has been put on hold.  The decision may be related to the departure of Marc Weidenbaum, who was VP of Original Publishing.

A mere delay, or a signal that the publisher is adopting a back-to-basics approach?  It would have been interesting to see what Viz could do with original content, considering the goal was not to replicate the ”oel” lines of other manga publishers, but to start a truly domestic graphic novel imprint.  Hopefully, this is a protracted schedule, not a total abandonment.

+++

A showdown is brewing between the Authors Guild of America and Amazon over the Kindle 2.0′s ability to read text aloud, which the guild maintains is a circumvention of author’s audio rights and may damage the audio book market.  The guild recommends that authors and publishers withhold books from the Kindle program unless Amazon also pays for audio rights.  On the other end, Amazon argues that a machine reading is far different from a recorded performance, although given the speed of technical advances in the field of voice synthesis (Hatsune Miku, anyone?), it isn’t inconceivable that one day machine readings will approach near-human quality.

The legal strength of the arguments notwithstanding, at this stage I think the text to speech function will be used most extensively by the visually impaired, so it would be a shame to take that functionality away.  Perhaps a new, cheaper licensing structure, one that covers exclusively this emerging technology, is in order.

+++

First, Futari H.  Now it’s Tantric Stripfighter Trina.  I think the evidence is piling up… Tokyopop is going to become an ero publisher!  Oh crap!

+++

ComiXpress, another POD specifically serving the comics market, has announced their intention to enter the distribution game as well.  Excerpt from their front page message:

ComiXpress is proud to announce that our Retail Distribution Service will be launching shortly. By offering the highest quality Print On Demand comics and trade paperbacks to retailers, the always important brick-and-mortar stores will have access to a catalog of some of the most amazing new comics coming out today.

Head on over to their website for more.

Now that there may be competition between POD printers, perhaps we might start seeing those discounts that so flustered many retailers start going up, eh?

Digg This
Reddit This
Stumble Now!
Buzz This
Vote on DZone
Share on Facebook
Bookmark this on Delicious
Kick It on DotNetKicks.com
Shout it
Share on LinkedIn
Bookmark this on Technorati
Post on Twitter
Google Buzz (aka. Google Reader)
  1. About the KINDLE thing – isn’t the audio reader the same version that Microsoft Reader used – where it sounds like a “bot-reader” reading the work.

    Isn’t part of the appeal of audiobooks the celebrity reader? What the Author’s Guild is saying makes no sense…they’re asking for royalties for something that’s programmed in for those who might have trouble reading [dyslexic or paralyzed] but still want to enjoy a book. KINDLE isn’t try to attach a celebrity voice to KINDLE programming or make eBooks available to those who want to hear a story while driving in the car.

    An audio function is not the same as ‘an audio book presentation’. Perhaps someone should remind the guild of that.

    Reply

    1. Functionally, yes, I agree what the Kindle does is the same as most accessability software available on almost every operating system. But motivation-wise I think this is a case of the Author’s Guild looking far into the future, sort of like the writer’s guild strike over *potential* internet royalties. One day, computers *will* be able to read books with all the nuances of a human performer, even simulate the speech mannerisms of a specific person, and that will likely render audio books obsolete. If the guild waits until then to issue guidance, it might be too late.

      Not that I’m in support of their position at this very moment, but it’s not completely baseless. This is a new area that needs to be hammered out.

      Reply

      1. The writer’s guild was fighting for shares of property that were all ready being sold in ways [Collection DVDs, online showings of first run episodes] that weren’t being paid to them. :/

        This is too early to be asking authors to boycott a product because of its possible evolutionary advancements. I agree, in time products like this will likely do what you’re saying they will– but not in the next five years. :/ Rather than lambasting KINDLE for being a potential issues in a decade or two– why not go after their publishers for putting eBooks on the market of their work, and charging the hardcover price?

        Choose the battle, as they say?

        :)

        Reply

        1. Oh, I agree the timing is off… that’s why I said I’m not in support of their position at the very moment.

          That’s also why I drew the SAG analogy… I felt they were in the right, but the timing of the strike was such that they probably lost a lot more money than if they had waited. Online wasn’t making a lot of money… and Kindle’s audio function probably won’t be costing authors a lot of money either.

          Reply

  2. @uk ero thing wouldnt the eroge game gibo (stepmother’s sin) also fall under this ban as well, along with other manga I’ve asked about simon lmao ^.^;
    Any idea what stripfight is about simon since the cover doesnt seem to tell much?

    Reply

    1. Haven’t seen the book. I just get a chuckle out of the title. Kama Sutra, tantric… they have a thing for the new-age, I guess.

      Reply

  3. About ComiXpress:

    I was interested when Ka-Blam announced its plans, but am less than enthusiastic about ComiXpress. Having had delays of several months getting comics I ordered from their online catalog sent to me, hearing horror stories of how much of a backlog and delay the company commonly has, I fear that unless they’re on the cusp of some major overhaul, ComiXpress isn’t going to be much of a factor in any developing POD-to-direct market distribution system.

    Not that I wish them ill, of course, and I’d love to see some healthy competition energize POD publishing, but past performance leaves me wary.

    Reply

    1. Come on, man, this year’s theme is HOPE! So Hope, goddamn it, Hoooope!

      Reply

    2. Here here– also, if you’re a manga maker [or graphic novel creator] POD is just not cost affective. :( Amazon’s own POD program can’t handle the pre-press, and places like KaBlam, LuLu, and ComixPress charge too high a base price to make it worth the hassle– you’d have to set your retail price far above the competition in order to meet most distributors asking take.

      Until a POD company comes along that can offer plans in ‘print runs’ of 50-100-500, and get that base price down to even a reasonable [but still pricey] $2-3 per book–creators will need to rely on printers and pay for their stock up front. :(

      Reply